Registered BAS Agent #26334941 Remote bookkeeping across NSW ☎ 0431 201 178 bellsbookkeeping47@gmail.com
Payroll

6 Costly Payroll Mistakes Australian Employers Make

By Maree Beltran, Registered BAS Agent · 18 Apr 2026

6 Costly Payroll Mistakes Australian Employers Make

Xero, MYOB or QuickBooks? All three are excellent — but the right fit depends on your business. Here's a practical comparison from a bookkeeper who works in all of them every day.

The big three at a glance

Over 75% of Australian small and mid-size businesses now use cloud accounting software. The market leaders here are Xero, MYOB and QuickBooks Online — and honestly, you can run a great business on any of them. The differences are in the details.

Xero

Loved for its clean, intuitive interface and excellent bank feeds. Xero is a favourite among small businesses and advisors, with a huge ecosystem of add-ons. Strong all-rounder, especially if you value ease of use.

MYOB

A long-established Australian platform with deep payroll and accounting capability. MYOB suits businesses that want robust, locally-focused features and have been in the Australian ecosystem for years.

QuickBooks Online

Competitively priced with strong reporting and a clean experience. Often a great value option for smaller businesses and sole traders.

How to choose

Rather than asking "which is best?", ask:

  • How complex is your payroll? Heavy award interpretation may steer the choice.
  • What does your accountant or bookkeeper use? Working in the same platform makes collaboration seamless.
  • What add-ons do you need? POS, job management, rostering and inventory all have preferred integrations.
  • What's your budget? Plans vary by features and user numbers.
The best software is the one that's set up correctly and actually used. A perfectly chosen platform that's a mess still gives you bad numbers.

Don't forget Employment Hero, NetSuite & Comrad

For payroll and HR, Employment Hero is increasingly popular. Larger or specialised businesses may run NetSuite (ERP) or industry systems like Comrad. Maree works across all of these, so whatever you're on, you're covered.

Let's get your software working for you

Maree can recommend, set up or clean up your accounting software and keep it running. See our accounting software services or ask Maree which platform suits your business.

Need a hand with this? Maree offers a free, no-obligation consultation. Get in touch →

Ready to take bookkeeping off your plate?

Talk to Maree about clean books, on-time BAS and stress-free payroll — wherever you are in NSW.